
Mp3 320 kbps. Scans.
The Complete Clef/Mercury Rec. Of Oscar Peterson Trio (#241)
DISCOGRAPHY
DISC I
1. Turtle Neck (A) 2:17
(Oscar Peterson)
2. It?s Easy To Remember (A) 3:25
(R. Rodgers-L. Hart)
3. Pooper (A) 2:52
(Oscar Peterson)
4. Love For Sale (A) 3:09
(Cole Porter)
5. Until The Real Thing Comes Along (A) 2:44
(S. Cahn-S. Chaplin-L.E. Freeman)
6. You Go To My Head (B) 3:52
(J.F. Coots-H. Gillespie)
7. They Can?t Take That Away From Me (B) 2:37
(G. Gershwin-I. Gershwin)
8. There?s A Small Hotel (B) 2:25
(R. Rodgers-L. Hart)
9. You Turned The Tables On Me (B) 3:07
(L. Alter-S. Mitchell)
10. These Foolish Things (B) 3:20
(Strachey-Marvell-Link)
11. I Can?t Get Started (B) 2:56
(V. Duke-I. Gershwin)
12. Blue Moon (B) 2:36
(L. Hart-R. Rodgers)
13. East Of The Sun (B) 2:57
(Brooks Bowman)
14. The Astaire Blues (C) 11:57
(Oscar Peterson)
DISC II
1. Tea For Two (C) 12:49
(V. Youmans-I. Caesar)
2. Slow Down (C) 12:17
(Oscar Peterson)
3. Oh, Lady Be Good (C) 12:05
(G & I Gershwin)
4. Body And Soul (C) 11:45
(Green-Heyman-Eyton-Sour)
5. Stompin? At The Savoy (C) 10:55
(Goodman-Razaf-Sampson-Webb)
6. Rough Ridin? (C) 2:44
(Fitzgerald-Jones-Tennyson)
7. Just One Of Those Things (C) 2:59
(Cole Porter)
8. Too Marvelous For Words (C) 2:47
(J. Mercer-R. Whiting)
9. But Not For Me (C) 2:28
(G & I Gershwin)
DISC III
1. That Makes A Difference To Me (D) 2:49
(Oscar Peterson)
2. Autumn In New York (D) 2:38
(Vernon Duke)
3. Pettiford?s Tune (Little Boy) (D) 3:10
(Oscar Peterson)
4. You Go To My Head (D) 2:47
(J.F. Coots-H. Gillespie)
5. Thou Swell (D) 2:27
(R. Rodgers-L. Hart)
6. Willow Weep For Me (D) 3:17
(Ann Ronnell)
7. Minor Blues (D) 2:40
(Oscar Peterson)
8. Pick Yourself Up (E) 3:20
(D. Fields-J. Kern)
9. Long Ago And Far Away (E) 3:44
(I. Gershwin-J. Kern)
10. Love Walked In (E) 3:05
(G & I Gershwin)
11. I Got Rhythm (E) 3:14
(G & I Gershwin)
12. A Fine Romance (E) 3:12
(D. Fields-J. Kern)
13. A Foggy Day (E) 3:35
(G & I. Gershwin)
14. Strike Up The Band ! (E) 3:13
(G & I. Gershwin)
15. The Man I Love (E) 3:29
(G & I. Gershwin)
16. Let?s Do It (E) 2:52
(Cole Porter)
17. It Ain?t Necessarily So (E) 3:11
(G & I. Gershwin)
18. I?ve Got My Love To Keep Me Warm (E) 2:46
(Irving Berlin)
19. I?ve Got A Crush On You (E) 2:50
(G & I. Gershwin)
20. Night And Day (E) 3:39
(Cole Porter)
21. Isn?t This A Lovely Day (E) 3:16
(Irving Berlin)
22. What Is This Thing Called Love ? (E) 3:07
(Cole Porter)
23. Willow Weep For Me (alt tk.-4) (D) 3:20
(Ann Ronnell)
DISC IV
1. Oh, Lady Be Good (E) 3:48
(G & I Gershwin)
2. ?S Wonderful (E) 2:35
(G & I. Gershwin)
3. Anything Goes (E) 2:55
(Cole Porter)
4. I?ve Got You Under My Skin (E) 2:27
(Cole Porter)
5. Fascinatin? Rhythm (E) 2:54
(G & I. Gershwin)
6. Cheek To Cheek (E) 2:59
(Irving Berlin)
7. I Got It Bad (And That Ain?t Good) (E) 3:09
(D. Ellington-P. Webster)
8. In A Mellow Tone (E) 3:05
(D. Ellington-M. Gabler)
9. I Love You (E) 3:03
(Cole Porter)
10. Somebody Loves Me (E) 3:21
(DeSylva-MacDonald-Gershwin)
11. I Was Doin? All Right (E) 2:39
(G & I. Gershwin)
12. In The Still Of The Night (E) 2:58
(Cole Porter)
13. Every Time We Say Goodbye (E) 3:23
(Cole Porter)
14. Just A-Sittin? And A-Rockin? (E) 3:39
(Strayhorn-Ellington-Gaines)
15. Begin The Beguine (E) 3:09
(Cole Porter)
16. So Near And Yet So Far (E) 3:18
(Cole Porter)
17. Blue Skies (E) 2:59
(Irving Berlin)
18. Take The ?A? Train (E) 3:13
(Billy Strayhorn)
19. Sophisticated Lady (E) 2:56
(Ellington-Parish-Mills)
20. Cotton Tail (E) 3:47
(Duke Ellington)
21. Prelude To A Kiss (E) 3:14
(Ellington-Gordon-Mills)
22. Things Ain?t What They Used To Be (E) 3:10
(Mercer Ellington)
23. Rockin? In Rhythm (E) 2:51
(Carney-Ellington-Mills)
DISC V
1. Do Nothin? Till You Hear From Me (E) 2:47
(D. Ellington-S. Russell)
2. Don?t Get Around Much Anymore (E) 3:55
(D. Ellington-S. Russell)
3. John Hardy?s Wife (E) 3:19
(Mercer Ellington)
4. Always (E) 2:48
(Irving Berlin)
5. Easter Parade (F) 3:12
(Irving Berlin)
6. Alexander?s Ragtime Band (F) 2:49
(Irving Berlin)
7. The Song Is Ended (F) 3:17
(Irving Berlin)
8. Say It Isn?t So (F) 3:06
(Irving Berlin)
9. Remember (F) 3:17
(Irving Berlin)
10. If I Had You (F) 3:09
(Campbell-Connelly-Shapiro)
11. How Deep Is The Ocean (F) 3:02
(Irving Berlin)
12. I?m Glad There Is You (G) 2:55
(J. Dorsey-P. Mertz)
13. Polka Dots And Moonbeams (G) 3:10
(J. Van Heusen-E. De Lange)
14. One For My Baby (G) 3:14
(J. Mercer-H. Arlen)
15. I Hear Music (G) 2:30
(B. Lane-F. Loesser)
16. Autumn In New York (G) 3:58
(Vernon Duke)
17. I Can?t Give You Anything But Love (G) 3:04
(D. Fields-J. McHugh)
18. Spring Is Here (G) 2:45
(R. Rodgers-L. Hart)
19. The Things We Did Last Summer (G) 4:00
(S. Cahn-J. Styne)
20. Streets Boogie (F) 3:19
(Oscar Peterson)
21. Booker T. Blues (F) 3:01
(Oscar Peterson)
DISC VI
1. Pompton Turnpike (LP tk.) (H) 6:42
(W. Osborne-D. Rogers)
2. Cherokee (H) 5:22
(Ray Noble)
3. Soft Winds (LP tk.) (H) 6:16
(Benny Goodman)
4. Carioca (H) 2:49
(Eliscu-Kahn-Youmans)
5. The Continental (H) 3:55
(C. Conrad-H. Magidson)
6. Tea For Two (H) 3:15
(V. Youmans-I. Caesar)
7. I Know That You Know (H) 3:48
(V. Youmans-A. Caldwell)
8. Hallelujah (H) 2:27
(Robin-Grey-Youmans)
9. Yesterdays (H) 2:32
(O. Harbach-J. Kern)
10. You Are Too Beautiful (H) 3:33
(R. Rodgers-L. Hart)
11. Isn?t It Romantic ? (H) 3:49
(R. Rodgers-L. Hart)
12. The Sheik Of Araby (H) 8:32
(H. Smith-T. Snyder)
13. There?ll Be Some Changes Made (H) 5:09
(B. Higgins-W. Overstreet)
14. Pompton Turnpike (78 tk.) (H) 4:24
(W. Osborne-D. Rogers)
15. Soft Winds (78 tk.) (H) 2:45
(Benny Goodman)
16. The Continental (alt tk.-1) (H) 3:59
(C. Conrad-H. Magidson)
DISC VII
1. Without A Song (I) 2:54
(Eliscu-Rose-Youmans)
2. Sometimes I?m Happy (I) 3:13
(Caesar-Youmans-Grey)
3. Time On My Hands (I) 2:36
(Adamson-Gordon-Youmans)
4. More Than You Know (I) 2:59
(Eliscu-Rose-Youmans)
5. This Can?t Be Love (I) 3:02
(L. Hart-R. Rodgers)
6. Blue Moon (I) 2:53
(L. Hart-R. Rodgers)
7. The Lady Is A Tramp (I) 2:52
(R. Rodgers-L. Hart)
8. It Might As Well Be Spring (I) 3:07
(R. Rodgers-O. Hammerstein)
9. Bewitched (I) 2:29
(R. Rodgers-L. Hart)
10. The Way You Look Tonight (I) 2:25
(D.Fields-J.Kern)
11. Ol? Man River (I) 3:19
(O. Hammerstein-J. Kern)
12. Can?t Help Lovin? That Man (I) 2:39
(O. Hammerstein-J. Kern)
13. The Song Is You (I) 2:24
(O. Hammerstein-J. Kern)
14. Lovely To Look At (I) 2:03
(Fields-Kern-McHugh)
15. Johnny One Note (I) 2:29
(R. Rodgers-L. Hart)
16. Smoke Gets In Your Eyes (I) 2:48
(O. Harbach-J. Kern)
17. Bill (I) 2:29
(Hammerstein-Kern-Wodehouse)
18. Look For The Silver Lining (I) 2:26
(B.G. DeSylva-J. Kern)
19. The Surrey With The Fringe On Top (I) 3:52
(R. Rodgers - O. Hammerstein)
20. Lover (I) 7:14
(R. Rodgers-L. Hart)
For the purposes of this discography, only the initial release of each matrix is listed. Clef issues in the 8900 or 89000 series are 78 and / or 45s. All others are LPs unless noted. EPs are listed here only if they are initial releases.
________________________________________________________________________
(A) OSCAR PETERSON TRIO: Oscar Peterson (p, vcl), Barney Kessel (g), Ray Brown (b).
LA, November 25, 1951
631-4 Turtle Neck ARS G415
632-8 It?s Easy To Remember Clef 89113, MGC 695
633-6 Pooper -
634-6 Love For Sale Clef/Merc 8959, MGC 603
635-5 Until The Real Thing
Comes Along (OP-vcl) - , MGC 127
Note: Some discographies list matrix 631 as being originally issued on Verve MGV 8341 College Album, however that LP was never released.
________________________________________________________________________
(B) OSCAR PETERSON TRIO: Oscar Peterson (p), Irving Ashby (g), Ray Brown (b).
LA, January 26, 1952
692-2 You Go To My Head Clef/Merc 89006, MGC 119
693-3 They Can?t Take
That Away From Me Clef 89009, -
694-3 There?s A Small Hotel Clef 89007, -
695-2 You Turned The Tables On Me Clef/Merc 89006, -
696-1 These Foolish Things Clef Merc 89008, -
697-2 I Can?t Get Started Clef 89007, -
698-1 Blue Moon Clef 89009, -
699-2 East Of The Sun Clef/Merc 89008, -
700-1 Funky Blues unissued, master no longer exists
Note: Some discographies show Willow Weep For Me as from this session, however, it is actually from the date of May/June 1952.
________________________________________________________________________
(C) OSCAR PETERSON QUARTET: Oscar Peterson (p, vcl), Barney Kessel (g), Ray Brown (b), Alvin Stoller (d).
LA, February 26, 1952
701-1 The Astaire Blues Clef MGC 116
702-1 Tea For Two ARS G415
703-1 Slow Down Clef MGC 698
704-1 Oh, Lady Be Good Clef MGC 168
705-1 Body And Soul -
706-1 Stompin? At The Savoy Clef MGC 116
707-2 Rough Ridin? Clef/Merc 8976, Clef MGC 127
708-1 Just One Of Those Things Clef/Merc 8999, Clef MGC 603
709-3 Too Marvelous
For Words (OP-vcl) -1 Verve MGV 2012
710-1 But Not For Me (OP-vcl) -1 Clef/Merc 8976, MGC 127
-1 omit Stoller.
________________________________________________________________________
(D) OSCAR PETERSON TRIO: Oscar Peterson (p, vcl), Barney Kessel (g), Ray Brown (b).
LA, May or June 1952
791-8 That Makes A Difference To Me (OP-vcl) previously unissued
792-5 Autumn In New York (OP-vcl) -
793-1 Pettiford?s Tune ?1 Clef 89139
794-5 You Go To My Head previously unissued
795-6 Thou Swell Clef MGC 624
796-3 Willow Weep For Me Clef/Merc 8999, MGC 694
796-4 Willow Weep For Me previously unissued
797-1 Minor Blues -
?1 Also known as Little Boy.
Discographies show 796-4 for the issued take of Willow Weep For Me.
________________________________________________________________________
(E) OSCAR PETERSON TRIO: Same as (D).
LA, early December 1952
896-2 Pick Yourself Up Clef MGC 623
897-2 Long Ago And Far Away -
898-2 Love Walked In Clef MGC 605
899-1 I Got Rhythm -
900-3 A Fine Romance Clef MGC 623
901-1 A Foggy Day Clef MGC 605
902-5 Strike Up The Band ! -
903-2 The Man I Love Clef 89038, MGC 605
904-1 Let?s Do It Clef 89077, MGC 603
905-3 It Ain?t Necessarily So Clef 89038, MGC 605
906-2 I?ve Got My Love
To Keep Me Warm Clef 89078, MGC 604
907-1 I?ve Got A Crush On You Clef MGC 605
908-6 Night And Day Clef MGC 603
909-5 Isn?t This A Lovely Day Clef 89039, MGC 604
910-1 What Is This Thing Called Love ? Clef 89040, MGC 603
911-2 Oh, Lady Be Good Clef 89076, MGC 605
912-4 ?S Wonderful Clef MGC 605
913-8 Anything Goes Clef MGC 603
914-1 I?ve Got You Under My Skin -
915-3 Fascinatin? Rhythm Clef MGC 605
916-8 Cheek To Cheek Clef 89078, MGC 604
917-5 I Got It Bad (And That Ain?t Good) Clef MGC 606
918-1 In A Mellow Tone -
919-3 I Love You Clef MGC 603
920-3 Somebody Loves Me Clef MGC 605
921-4 I Was Doin? All Right Clef 89076, MGC 605
922-2 In The Still Of The Night Clef 89040, MGC 603
923-3 Every Time We Say Goodbye Clef MGC 603
924-1 Just A-Sittin? And A-Rockin? Clef MGC 606
925-3 Begin The Beguine Clef 89077, MGC 603
926-3 So Near And Yet So Far Clef MGC 603
927-3 Blue Skies Clef 89039, MGC 604
928-5 Take The ?A? Train Clef MGC 606
929-2 Sophisticated Lady Clef 89079, MGC 606
930-4 Cotton Tail - -
931-1 Prelude To A Kiss Clef 89041, -
932-1 Things Ain?t What
They Used To Be Clef MGC 606
933-2 Rockin? In Rhythm -
934-6 Do Nothin? Till You Hear From Me -
935-2 Don?t Get Around Much Anymore -
936-1 John Hardy?s Wife Clef 89041, MGC 606
937-3 Always Clef MGC 604
Note: There are no exact recording dates for the above ?session? except that some discographies list that all of Clef MGC 603 was recorded on November 25, 1952 and the following probably recorded between November 1 and December 4, 1952.
________________________________________________________________________
(F) OSCAR PETERSON TRIO: Same as (D).
LA, c. December 1952
942-1 Easter Parade Clef MGC 604
943-1 Alexander?s Ragtime Band -
944-1 The Song Is Ended -
945-1 Say It Isn?t So -
946-1 Remember -
947-3 If I Had You -
948-1 How Deep Is The Ocean -
949-5 Streets Boogie -1 Norgran 123
950-1 Booker T. Blues -1 -
-1 issued as ?Tank Butterball?. Norgran 123 was released as both a 78 and 45 RPM issue.
(G) OSCAR PETERSON TRIO: Same as (D) except all titles have vocals by Peterson.
NYC, May 21, 1953
1230-1 I?m Glad There Is You Clef EPC 191 (EP)
1231-1 Polka Dots And Moonbeams Clef 89106
1232-1 One For My Baby -
1233-3 I Hear Music Clef 89093
1234-2 Autumn In New York -
1235-4 I Can?t Give You Anything But Love Clef 89062
1236-3 Spring Is Here -
1237-2 The Things We Did Last Summer Clef EPC 192 (EP)
Note: All titles also issued on Clef MGC 145.
Some discographies list matrices 1233 and 1234 as being issued on Clef 89063 (78), however, that catalog number was used for a Ben Webster release.
________________________________________________________________________
(H) OSCAR PETERSON TRIO: Same as (D).
LA, December 6, 1953
1329-1 Pompton Turnpike Clef MGC 694
1329-3 Pompton Turnpike Clef 89127
1330-1 Cherokee Clef MGC 694
1331-1 Soft Winds -
1331-2 Soft Winds Clef 89148
1332-5 Carioca Clef EPC 218 (EP), MGC 625
1333-1 The Continental previously unissued
1333-3 The Continental Clef MGC 694
1334-1 Tea For Two Clef 89127, MGC 625
1335-1 I Know That You Know Clef EPC 219 (EP), MGC 625
1336-2 Hallelujah Clef EPC 217 (EP), MGC 625
1337-3 Yesterdays Clef EPC 213 (EP), MGC 623
1338-2 You Are Too Beautiful Clef MGC 695
1339-2 Isn?t It Romantic ? Clef EPC 214 (EP), MGC 624
1340-3 The Sheik Of Araby (OP-vcl) previously unissued
1341-1 There?ll Be Some Changes Made -
Note: Discographies list matrix 1329-2 on Clef 89127, however, that take is a breakdown. Matrix 1333-1 is sometimes listed as the issued take. Also incorrectly given in discographies is matrix 1336-1 as the master take, however, that as well a breakdown. Matrix 1340 is listed as unissued but with -1 and -2 being the takes.
________________________________________________________________________
(I) OSCAR PETERSON TRIO: Same as (D).
LA, December 7, 1953
1342-1 Without A Song Clef EPC 218 (EP), MGC 625
1343-1 Sometimes I?m Happy - -
1344-3 Time On My Hands Clef EPC 219 (EP), -
1345-2 More Than You Know Clef EPC 217 (EP), -
1346-5 This Can?t Be Love Clef EPC 215 (EP), MGC 624
1347-1 Blue Moon Clef EPC 214 (EP), -
1348-2 The Lady Is A Tramp Clef EPC 215 (EP), -
1349-3 It Might As Well Be Spring Clef EPC 216 (EP), -
1350-1 Bewitched - -
1351-1 The Way You Look Tonight Clef EPC 211 (EP), MGC 623
1352-2 Ol? Man River - -
1353-1 Can?t Help Lovin? That Man Clef EPC 212 (EP), -
1354-2 The Song Is You - -
1355-3 Lovely To Look At - -
1356-3 Johnny One Note Clef EPC 216 (EP), MGC 624
1357-3 Smoke Gets In Your Eyes Clef EPC 213 (EP), MGC 623
1358-2 Bill Clef EPC 211 (EP), MGC 623
1359-1 Look For The Silver Lining Clef MGC 695
1360-1 The Surrey With The Fringe On Top Clef EPC 216 (EP), MGC 624
1361-2 Lover Clef EPC 214 (EP), MGC 624
Note: Discographies list matrix 1349 as being issued with -2.
________________________________________________________________________
ALBUM INDEX:
78 ALBUMS
Clef C-119 (89006-89009) Oscar Peterson
EPs:
Clef EPC 191 Oscar Peterson Sings
Clef EPC 192 Oscar Peterson Sings
Clef EPC 211 Oscar Peterson Plays Jerome Kern
Clef EPC 212 Oscar Peterson Plays Jerome Kern
Clef EPC 213 Oscar Peterson Plays Jerome Kern
Clef EPC 214 Oscar Peterson Plays Richard Rodgers
Clef EPC 215 Oscar Peterson Plays Richard Rodgers
Clef EPC 216 Oscar Peterson Plays Richard Rodgers
Clef EPC 217 Oscar Peterson Plays Vincent Youmans
Clef EPC 218 Oscar Peterson Plays Vincent Youmans
Clef EPC 219 Oscar Peterson Plays Vincent Youmans
10? LPs:
Clef MGC 116 The Oscar Peterson Quartet
Clef MGC 119 Oscar Peterson Plays Pretty
Clef MGC 127 Oscar Peterson Collates no.2
Clef MGC 168 The Oscar Peterson Quartet No.2
12? LPs:
American Recording Society G415 An Oscar For Peterson
Clef MGC 603 Oscar Peterson Plays Cole Porter
Clef MGC 604 Oscar Peterson Plays Irving Berlin
Clef MGC 605 Oscar Peterson Plays George Gershwin
Clef MGC 606 Oscar Peterson Plays Duke Ellington
Clef MGC 623 Oscar Peterson Plays Jerome Kern
Clef MGC 624 Oscar Peterson Plays Richard Rodgers
Clef MGC 625 Oscar Peterson Plays Vincent Youmans
Clef MGC 694 Recital by Oscar Peterson
Clef MGC 695 Nostalgic Memories By Oscar Peterson
Clef MGC 698 An Evening With Oscar Peterson Duo/Quartet
Verve MGV 2012 Romance - The Vocal Styling of Oscar Peterson
Original sessions supervised by Norman Granz
Produced for release by Scott Wenzel
Executive producer: Michael Cuscuna
Tape transfers: Ellen Fitton
Additional disc transfers: Malcolm Addey, Dr. Michael Arie, Mark Wilder
Sound restoration and mastering by Malcolm Addey.
24 bit technology was utilized at all stages of the production of this Mosaic release.
13 comentarios:
http://rapidshare.com/files/374247515/Disc_1.part1.rar
http://rapidshare.com/files/374263532/Disc_1.part2.rar
http://rapidshare.com/files/374265696/Disc_2.part1.rar
http://rapidshare.com/files/374237421/Disc_2.part2.rar
http://rapidshare.com/files/374451872/Disc_3.part1.rar
http://rapidshare.com/files/374464468/Disc_3.part2.rar
http://rapidshare.com/files/374472283/Disc_4.part1.rar
http://rapidshare.com/files/374484570/Disc_4.part2.rar
http://rapidshare.com/files/374492531/Disc_5.part1.rar
http://rapidshare.com/files/374504017/Disc_5.part2.rar
http://rapidshare.com/files/374510697/Disc_6.part1.rar
http://rapidshare.com/files/374444718/Disc_6.part2.rar
http://rapidshare.com/files/374579808/Disc_7.part1.rar
http://rapidshare.com/files/374573917/Disc_7.part2.rar
http://rapidshare.com/files/374596355/Booklet.rar
http://rapidshare.com/files/374698328/Covers.rar
Dear Jasapaal,
Your love and admiration for Oscar is clear. He is a pianist I have ignored for too long. Now, thanks to your wonderful blog, you give me the chance to educate myself about OP's art
Thank you so much !
Yours in Music,
Censusloss
Oscar Peterson Trio - Complete Clef_Mercury Studio Recordings (1951-1953)
Amazing.
Simply amazing.
This is the definitive edition of this material. One of Peterson's most productive periods. Carefully restored & remastered.
I make mine the anonimous words above. Thank you very much for this splendid post (Oscar Peterson Trio - Complete Clef_Mercury Studio Recordings (1951-1953)
What a unbelievable post for an Oscar Peterson nerd. Many, many thanks Jasapaal.
You are very welcome to Peterson love Censusloss.
Forever grateful......this is a treasure!
It took me a long time to learn to dig Oscar Peterson. Maybe if I'd started with the Complete Clef_Mercury Studio Recordings...
Thanks!
Enjoy it troods.
Welcome Frank. I think it's easy love to Oscar Peterson
Wow!!! What a dazzling treat!!!
A tremendous amount of work done on this one, sir, but it's all worth it!! Simply excellent!!
Kneigh
Am a bit late in finding your blog, but what a trip and an amazing journey I have had since discovery. Commendations for this collection of the Complete Clef recordings from Oscar Peterson.
You are welcome Bill M. Enjoy it with all Peterson's friends.
Publicar un comentario